Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Dear Sony

Reply
Created by evlPanda > 9 months ago, 8 Dec 2008
evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
8 Dec 2008 7:08PM
Thumbs Up

Dear Sony,

(see lift out brochure in today's Courier Mail if you have).
Your add for the 200HZ Bravias is full of marketing lies.

A) You are confusing refresh rate, Hertz, with Frames Per Second (FPS). You think you'd get this right it being the crux of the technology for the advertisement.

The two have nothing in common. 50HZ does not = 50FPS. It's akin to saying 200HP = 8litres/100km, or 20kg = orange.

B) Therefore everything else is incorrect. The figure comparing the difference in images between 50hz and 200hz is incorrect. There will not magically be more frames of the ball as it moves. The frames aren't there to begin with. They never existed when the footage was captured at ~24 FPS. End of story.

C) The second diagram shows 5 frames. The first is labelled 1/200 sec, the last 2/200 sec. There are three in the middle. We can count. What you have illustrated here is 4 frames for each 1/200 sec, or an 800hz system.

Your sincerely,
Sick of this bull****.

MintoxGT
WA, 975 posts
8 Dec 2008 5:49PM
Thumbs Up

Dude.... This is seabreeze and umm not Sony!

But I like your style, now go tell SONY that and ask for something in return, we need clever people like you to save dummies like me from the big multi nationals........Attack em boy!!!![}:)]

Good luck mate

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
8 Dec 2008 6:03PM
Thumbs Up

It's a PHONY!

PHONY are THE most overated, overpriced gear EVER.

Most folks that buy PHONY wouldn't even take the time to read the phony blurb - let alone discern the inaccuracies. People buy PHONY because it has a nice obvious PHONY badge that all their PHONY luvin friends will notice..

Stay away unless you have more dollars than sense.

DL
WA, 659 posts
8 Dec 2008 6:43PM
Thumbs Up

Maybe the Sony product can interpolate between frames?

theDoctor
NSW, 5786 posts
8 Dec 2008 8:47PM
Thumbs Up

hmmmmm.... and yet i have always been told that watching television makes you stupid

Gestalt
QLD, 14997 posts
8 Dec 2008 8:08PM
Thumbs Up

theDoctor said...

hmmmmm.... and yet i have always been told that watching television makes you stupid


only if you watch channel 10.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
8 Dec 2008 9:26PM
Thumbs Up

getfunky said...

It's a PHONY!

PHONY are THE most overated, overpriced gear EVER.

Most folks that buy PHONY wouldn't even take the time to read the phony blurb - let alone discern the inaccuracies. People buy PHONY because it has a nice obvious PHONY badge that all their PHONY luvin friends will notice..

Stay away unless you have more dollars than sense.


Not true. Sony makes awesome amps, they are solid units that keep going. Sony also makes great projectors for home theatre. Once I win lotto I'm gonna get one. Till then I'll keep using my cheapo data projector at home.

OceanBlue64
VIC, 980 posts
8 Dec 2008 9:40PM
Thumbs Up

Mobydisc said...

getfunky said...

It's a PHONY!

PHONY are THE most overated, overpriced gear EVER.

Most folks that buy PHONY wouldn't even take the time to read the phony blurb - let alone discern the inaccuracies. People buy PHONY because it has a nice obvious PHONY badge that all their PHONY luvin friends will notice..

Stay away unless you have more dollars than sense.


Not true. Sony makes awesome amps, they are solid units that keep going. Sony also makes great projectors for home theatre. Once I win lotto I'm gonna get one. Till then I'll keep using my cheapo data projector at home.



You obviously havent had to fix many then lol. Come and visit my workplace if you are ever in Geelong and I will show you a few

evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
8 Dec 2008 10:37PM
Thumbs Up

If I get bored enough there's a new Sony Centre up the road from me. I might go in and ask a salesman how 200hz makes 4x the frame rate.

"So the movie was 24 frame/sec and now it's ...96!? Hang on... 96? You said this was 200hz!"

Could be fun.

DL
WA, 659 posts
8 Dec 2008 8:47PM
Thumbs Up

re: my interpolation comment.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow-motion

It's not impossible that 4 intermediate frames are being calculated between each broadcast frame, but I doubt that a TV would have that sort of processing power.

DL
WA, 659 posts
8 Dec 2008 8:50PM
Thumbs Up

On further reading, the Bravia seems to do post processing between frames.

www.sony.co.uk/electronics/support

MavericK040
WA, 583 posts
8 Dec 2008 10:31PM
Thumbs Up

Sony is overrated,

take a look at the sony range of Car audio gear , absolutely terrible!

but everyone raves about it - why?? cos its sony.

but if you look at perhaps some of the better less well known brands that are more expensive you will get much better quality. like Alpine For example.

I like Alpine Is Alpine is good , Is sony is bad.

A good mate of mine works at a specialist home theater type of store, he reckons Pioneer make the best LCD or is it plasma ? TVs

Which i was supprised by cos Pioneer make some crap Car gear aswell.

(DISCLAIMER) i know car gear is not home gear , and i know that the competition level pioneer gear is pretty good and that pioneer used to be the stuff to have in your car - unforunately not any more.

OceanBlue64
VIC, 980 posts
9 Dec 2008 8:47AM
Thumbs Up

Sorry but as a repairer, Pioneer dont get my vote either lol. For value for money vs quality in the LCD range, we find that the new Samsungs are hard to beat.

When it comes to home theater I cant really say I like any of them. They are all over rated, poorly designed (from a service point of view) and way too expensive for what you get. The current Harmon Kardon range are ok but nothing to write home about.

cRAZY Canuk
NSW, 2528 posts
9 Dec 2008 10:30AM
Thumbs Up

OceanBlue64 said...
For value for money vs quality in the LCD range, we find that the new Samsungs are hard to beat.


Was going to say I've got nothing but nice things to say about our samsung stuff.

But then again it's a tv who cares, do you watch enough or a little of it that those extra frames will make a differance?

evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
9 Dec 2008 2:32PM
Thumbs Up

DL said...

On further reading, the Bravia seems to do post processing between frames.

www.sony.co.uk/electronics/support


OK... after (actually) reading that I may have to go and see for myself.

Mark _australia
WA, 23746 posts
9 Dec 2008 4:07PM
Thumbs Up

i hope you send that (your O.P) to Sony too

MavericK040
WA, 583 posts
9 Dec 2008 6:30PM
Thumbs Up

OceanBlue64 said...

Sorry but as a repairer, Pioneer dont get my vote either lol. For value for money vs quality in the LCD range, we find that the new Samsungs are hard to beat.

When it comes to home theater I cant really say I like any of them. They are all over rated, poorly designed (from a service point of view) and way too expensive for what you get. The current Harmon Kardon range are ok but nothing to write home about.


Dont be sorry mate , i dont like pioneer either. i heard that samsung are now making the pioneer tvs?

Most equipment is not built from a servicemans P.O.V. im a mechanic and not a day goes by where i say why the fk did those idiots put that there in the way of that.

Mark _australia
WA, 23746 posts
9 Dec 2008 7:06PM
Thumbs Up

Mechanic? I sympatise with you... back in the day when I was a rev head with fast Jap cars, I think we came to the conclusion that somewhere in Japan there is a few guys with 6ft long arms and 8 fingers per hand.... so that is what you need to get to some of the stuff on modern cars.

(PS: mine was a 93 Laser TX3 4WD with 240 Kw at flywheel I miss her...)

MavericK040
WA, 583 posts
9 Dec 2008 7:50PM
Thumbs Up

Yep Japanese cars are the worst for that.

My hiace is an absolute Moll to work on. luckily it hasnt really fkd up yet. ( note to anyone who knows me and my car - the recent fk up Re diff mount was my fault , van meets rocks = realignment of diff )

Fast jap cars. . . mmm i like

My mate has a Series 5 RX7 13b turbo intercooled , very quick.

My dream car is a Series 8 RX7 Twin turbo blah blah.
Would have one now but i hardly fit in it let alone windsurfing gear!



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Dear Sony" started by evlPanda