Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

S.E. QLD disaster ship

Reply
Created by Richiefish > 9 months ago, 12 Mar 2009
Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
12 Mar 2009 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

Should ships carrying loose deck containers be allowed to steam flat out towards a cyclone whilst traveling 7 km offshore from a pristine national park ??? ..The white sands of Moreton Island are black and stinking. The mess (oil spill) is now spreading to the Sunshine coast....You hear about this stuff happening overseas and cringe. When it happens in your own back yard its absolutely sickening..... News- Moreton Island, Bribie Island,and parts of the Sunshine Coast have now been officially declared "disaster areas"......

So they of course bring the ship into brisbane where it is now leaking fuel oil into the Brisbane river......

GypsyDrifter
WA, 2371 posts
12 Mar 2009 7:36PM
Thumbs Up

Something is usually done after the fact!!!
Not happy Jan!

echunda
VIC, 765 posts
12 Mar 2009 9:45PM
Thumbs Up

DUMB, DUMB DUMB,

The company should be put on trial for stupidity!

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
14 Mar 2009 12:16AM
Thumbs Up

I find it f@cking incredulous that nobody has anything to say about what is described as the biggest ecological disaster in the history of SE QLD. Two comments till now from people from inter state. I'm not often serious but apathy truely sucks !!!.......oooo my mast is stuck .......@#$%&*

poor relative
WA, 9106 posts
14 Mar 2009 9:14AM
Thumbs Up

Its ****ing incredible.
What i'd like to know is who authorised the boat to pull into the harbour and not quarantine the immediate areas with booms.
Pure fkn genius.
Also why the delay in clean up?
There are lots and lots of questions that need to be answered.

Gestalt
QLD, 14997 posts
14 Mar 2009 10:19AM
Thumbs Up

a mate went windsurfing in the stuff at the caloundra bar.

said he was sailing along, hit the slick and the board went all skatey. said it was wierd feeling.

Cal
QLD, 1003 posts
14 Mar 2009 10:31AM
Thumbs Up

I have been trying to volunteer to help with wildlife etc for the past 2 days, there appears to be no coordinated response at all. What has happened to the emergency plan that all ports must maintain on standby at all times ???

surfingboye
NSW, 2707 posts
14 Mar 2009 12:07PM
Thumbs Up

Hey Richie, check out this thread. It just shows how much us kiters care about the environment, compared to the selfcentered poleys.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=48751

patsken
WA, 717 posts
14 Mar 2009 3:35PM
Thumbs Up

Loose containers ????

I don't think so.

Locked and lashed!!!

As a sailboarder you should understand the power of the wind and especially the waves......

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
14 Mar 2009 5:51PM
Thumbs Up

And this is the reason that im so opposed to nuclear power......
"Trust the Government and big business to keep us safe" .... not for me!!!
If the oils was radio active .... imagine the problem then?

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
14 Mar 2009 5:26PM
Thumbs Up

surfingboye said...

Hey Richie, check out this thread. It just shows how much us kiters care about the environment, compared to the selfcentered poleys.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=48751


this is posted on the "general forum" Maybe poleys only read the windsurfing section and teabaggers only read the kiting section ??? Dont take the rivalry so seriously. Its just some we do for a laugh when there's no wind. This oil spill is beyond all that BS.

GypsyDrifter
WA, 2371 posts
14 Mar 2009 5:49PM
Thumbs Up

Frankly Richiefish..
I am lost for words...this is a disaster (to me) as bad..at the bush fires and the floods.

If I could physically help (as I am in WA) I would be down doing my 2cents worth..

I find this disaster...massive..because it is in the water...and to get a handle on the magnitude of what this stuff is going to kill and affect for years to come I can't comprehend (at least I am honest)
My lack of words in this post..may reflect what others feel too!..or maybe not!

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
14 Mar 2009 6:58PM
Thumbs Up

patsken said...

Loose containers ????

I don't think so.

Locked and lashed!!!

As a sailboarder you should understand the power of the wind and especially the waves......


Are you under the impression that shipping containers rarely fall off ships ???
you must be kidding ????

vermanator
QLD, 3 posts
14 Mar 2009 10:14PM
Thumbs Up

if you think thats f**king incredible, a week ago the epa started to inforce their new green zones in moreton bay and moreton island to help with depleating fish stocks, now their green zones are black zones so much for protecting our fish stocks,how long now will it take for these areas to recover? and why the delay, because the idiots couldnt deceide which department was going to supply the man power and wear the costs, time to put someone else in charge, anybody could do a better job, anybody could do better than these pack of twits

poor relative said...

Its ****ing incredible.
What i'd like to know is who authorised the boat to pull into the harbour and not quarantine the immediate areas with booms.
Pure fkn genius.
Also why the delay in clean up?
There are lots and lots of questions that need to be answered.


patsken
WA, 717 posts
15 Mar 2009 1:48AM
Thumbs Up

RichieRich .... I am under the impression you don't actually know what you are talking about -- on this point.

I do actually work in the industry. Containers are locked with "rated" twistlocks to each other and the deck of the ship and then lashed with turnbuckles and rigid rods to the deck. DEFINITELY not loose as you stated.

I HAVE seen vessels arrive in port with mangled and twisted containers (also gaps where they have been smashed overboard) by heavy seas in the Bight.A winter storm -- not a cyclone. So yes they do go overboard, albeit not nearly as many times as I stuff up a gybe and you imply.

I understand the upset an event like this causes and I too am pi__ed off about it but uninformed comments like yours do not help the situation. You obviously live in Queensland and probably enjoy the benefits of a lifestyle built on an economy sustained by exports of mined products and imported boards and sails and X-Boxes. Do they arrive with Santa? - I don't think so. My kids think they do. They actually come by ship. Ships are actually quite necessary I think and a lot less polluting (usually) than trucks and planes.

This tragedy may well be caused by human error and lack of judgment but please stick to facts 'cos an Australian shipping industry is better than a foreign "flag of convenience" shipping industry, which is better than trucks on the road etc etc etc.

The whole system of pollution control seems to have had a meltdown because to have the incident happen in the first place is most likely bad fortune or maybe stupidity but to then pollute the Brissie River has got to be an absolute clusterf_ck of monumental proportions.

It's probably a good time to pressure the government to beef up the pollution response methods while the election is happening and try and protect what is one of Ozzes great coastline regions.

Off my soapbox now.

Good luck.....

NDH47
NSW, 102 posts
15 Mar 2009 11:29AM
Thumbs Up

The media seem to be overlooking the magnitude of this. The big news is those relief concerts & someones dug up some nude photos of pauline hanson

The only response I've seen from the QLD gov is how long they think it'll take to clean it up & where's krudd during this.......

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
15 Mar 2009 11:35AM
Thumbs Up

patsken said...

RichieRich .... I am under the impression you don't actually know what you are talking about -- on this point.

I do actually work in the industry. Containers are locked with "rated" twistlocks to each other and the deck of the ship and then lashed with turnbuckles and rigid rods to the deck. DEFINITELY not loose as you stated.

I HAVE seen vessels arrive in port with mangled and twisted containers (also gaps where they have been smashed overboard) by heavy seas in the Bight.A winter storm -- not a cyclone. So yes they do go overboard, albeit not nearly as many times as I stuff up a gybe and you imply.

I understand the upset an event like this causes and I too am pi__ed off about it but uninformed comments like yours do not help the situation. You obviously live in Queensland and probably enjoy the benefits of a lifestyle built on an economy sustained by exports of mined products and imported boards and sails and X-Boxes. Do they arrive with Santa? - I don't think so. My kids think they do. They actually come by ship. Ships are actually quite necessary I think and a lot less polluting (usually) than trucks and planes.

This tragedy may well be caused by human error and lack of judgment but please stick to facts 'cos an Australian shipping industry is better than a foreign "flag of convenience" shipping industry, which is better than trucks on the road etc etc etc.

The whole system of pollution control seems to have had a meltdown because to have the incident happen in the first place is most likely bad fortune or maybe stupidity but to then pollute the Brissie River has got to be an absolute clusterf_ck of monumental proportions.

It's probably a good time to pressure the government to beef up the pollution response methods while the election is happening and try and protect what is one of Ozzes great coastline regions.

Off my soapbox now.

Good luck.....



Its true , I am spouting off a bit about this whole incident. I live on a boat so Moreton bay is my backyard.(Thus I take it a bit personally.)
You are obviously very knowedgable on this subject so perhaps you could clarify for me the subject of ship ETAs. If this skipper had pulled his speed back to say, 15 knots for 12 hours and perhaps changed course, would the delay incur "trouble" ie. is there pressure on the captain to be there on time regardless. I've heard some captains knock their ETA back 12 hours to give themselves a safety buffer.Others cant do this ????

patsken
WA, 717 posts
15 Mar 2009 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

I have heard in the press that the Captain is inexperienced and made some bad decisions and faces charges (GOOD) - bleeding obvious that snippet of info. Schedules can be made up so I wouldn't think that was the reason he chose to carry on rather than point into weather.

Most likely just not enough experience to help make the right decisions and look what happens - a disaster which has ruined the coastline and it's probably only luck that there were no humans lost.

Like a lot of things in life I would think that he wishes he had made a couple of different choices.

Good luck with the clean up.........

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
15 Mar 2009 10:29PM
Thumbs Up

mmm I'm worried about pressure from companies on captains to meet ETAs. Especially inexperienced guys worried about their job. Similar to truck drivers but with a much higher potential for disaster. Imagine a ship of this size breaking up on the Great Barrier Reef......The blame game allways seems to happen AFTER the event...when its too late....

shark
WA, 361 posts
17 Mar 2009 12:22AM
Thumbs Up

Richiefish said...

patsken said...

Loose containers ????

I don't think so.

Locked and lashed!!!

As a sailboarder you should understand the power of the wind and especially the waves......


Are you under the impression that shipping containers rarely fall off ships ???
you must be kidding ????


They are lashed and locked down but it isnt foolproof

shark
WA, 361 posts
17 Mar 2009 12:31AM
Thumbs Up

GypsyDrifter said...

Frankly Richiefish..
I am lost for words...this is a disaster (to me) as bad..at the bush fires and the floods.

If I could physically help (as I am in WA) I would be down doing my 2cents worth..

I find this disaster...massive..because it is in the water...and to get a handle on the magnitude of what this stuff is going to kill and affect for years to come I can't comprehend (at least I am honest)
My lack of words in this post..may reflect what others feel too!..or maybe not!


Im suprised that no-one has commented on your post-are you kidding? 200 odd people burnt to death? You must be off with the fairies if you think there is any comparison between the two.

Horrible as an oil spill is, it will clean up with time. And yes I work in the maritime industry and have a bit to do with spill response, albeit in the early stages of a response.

patsken
WA, 717 posts
17 Mar 2009 10:25AM
Thumbs Up

Shark--

Nothing is foolproof when there may well have been an idiot in control

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
17 Mar 2009 7:56PM
Thumbs Up

patsken said...

Shark--

Nothing is foolproof when there may well have been an idiot in control


no comment on the issue of captains being pressured by "the company" ???
I've seen it happen in the tourist charter industry.

GypsyDrifter
WA, 2371 posts
17 Mar 2009 8:41PM
Thumbs Up

shark said...

Select to expand quote



Im suprised that no-one has commented on your post-are you kidding? 200 odd people burnt to death? You must be off with the fairies if you think there is any comparison between the two.

Horrible as an oil spill is, it will clean up with time. And yes I work in the maritime industry and have a bit to do with spill response, albeit in the early stages of a response.


Your taking my words to suit your own thinking.
I'm not referring to lives lost!..(in no way shape or form)
I'm only referring to the land the bush fires have destroyed and the damage the floods have done to the land..and now the oil to the water

All these things going on in our backyard...all these things which need immediate attention..which I feel won't come quick enough



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"S.E. QLD disaster ship" started by Richiefish