Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > Kitesurfing General

right of way in the surf

Reply
Created by TurtleHunter > 9 months ago, 12 Oct 2010
TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
12 Oct 2010 2:56PM
Thumbs Up

Talking to another kiter who comes from a windsurfing background the other day and we realised we have completely different versions.
To me if your coming in on a wave those heading out should keep clear.
He mentioned that windsurfers give way to the person heading out and kiting would be the same.
So I pulled the trump card and told him I am the local.
But seriously I often have to pull off a wave or scape through under someones kite who is heading out and I always thought it was just a lack of judgement but maybe I am the only one following my rules. Then again I have never had the problem with windsurfers heading out.
I can imagine it also depends on local conditions like in flat water where one place works when starboard has right of way and others work better if port has right of way.

bennie
ACT, 1258 posts
12 Oct 2010 6:03PM
Thumbs Up

As far as I'm concerned if someones riding a wave they have right of way.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
12 Oct 2010 3:11PM
Thumbs Up

So what about windsurfers does the person on the wave ever make room for someone heading out
I knew I should of put money on it.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
12 Oct 2010 4:51PM
Thumbs Up

Here we go again..

Does a strapless kiter have RoW over a strapped?


It comes down to this - if the break is off a defined spot (like a point or reef etc) then the usual 1st on a wave applies.

If it is in the sort of never ending mush of onshore slop like Perf metro - it's pretty bloody hard to call where the beak (which kn one?) actually is.

Also, if you have ridden a wave into shore there is not a lot of room to move if another rider comes past on a wave too - due to the Perf mush breaking very close to shore.

So (IMO) you default to the 1st in the area has RoW. Hard to call and riding a twinny I know my lines and approch to the mush is diff to a surfboard rider for a number of reasons, so it gets trickier again.


SURFBOARDS do not have any kind of priority over twinns (and vice versa) tho -as much as that will be shock to a lot of SB riders. They are both watercraft and if you think SBs pull priority over twinnies your just a complete conceded wave snob.

If a rider of any sort is upwind of me - actually in the breaking mush I will vacate and fang out the back until they pass. And yes - if it is poss to head for the white water, rather than mush face - do it. Can be tricky if a rider pulls in just downwind, forcing you to put your kite high tho.

What bakes my biccies is when I am in the mush and some lame twit cruises in downwind from me pulling into the mush that I am already (IMO) in a priority posi for.

As I say it's pretty bloody hard to define where the break(s) are in Metro slop, so most times it's either perception of the break(s) or plain "all for me" that drives potential conflict from drop-in artistes. Often it's both and after opting out a number of times in a row, to downwind drop-ins, it's hard not to be tempted to cry "Jamm it upya freckle!! I'm comin thru this time sh!thead!"


Give n take is the best option. Metro hardly has world class waves so give way on a few, signal priority on a few, and make the best of the mush.

spot1
WA, 1588 posts
12 Oct 2010 4:53PM
Thumbs Up

bennie said...

As far as I'm concerned if someones riding a wave they have right of way.


right on
if you are heading out------ head for the white water not the face

lancekenny
SA, 402 posts
12 Oct 2010 7:43PM
Thumbs Up

locally we always give it to the guy on the wave - regardless of craft - when someone is on the wave the wave is their focus - not what is going on around it regards people getting into the lineup - obviously you do need to have some awareness of what is coming your way - but we all make every attempt possible to let the person on the wave go for it... I like how its done at margs... just a big rotation from out the back to inside and back again... the guys there have it sorted.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
12 Oct 2010 5:53PM
Thumbs Up

Lance be speaking the sense.. yo.

Er.. I've been watching too many eps of Breaking Bad.. yo.

terminal
1421 posts
12 Oct 2010 6:05PM
Thumbs Up

TurtleHunter said...

So what about windsurfers does the person on the wave ever make room for someone heading out
I knew I should of put money on it.


Yes they do. They are supposed to make use of a channel if there is one.
If there is no channel and the surf is big enough for them not to be able to climb over white water, then they need to find their way out over unbroken faces and the windsurfer going out has right of way over the rider on the wave.

eg. in the O'Neill Wave Classic, Robby Naish was going out and did an inverted semi-jump on a wave that Mike Waltze was riding and their masts touched. Mike apologised to Robby afterwards. That was a special case in that they were in a competition so were jumping too and didn't have to use the channel.

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
12 Oct 2010 7:55PM
Thumbs Up

TurtleHunter said...

So what about windsurfers does the person on the wave ever make room for someone heading out


Occasionally they do, but mostly they don't get into that situation because the wave rider is on the critical section, which is just where the guy heading out does NOT want to be.

If you spot a good lipping ramp then it's considered very bad form to go for it without checking that no-one's on the wave first. I normally give wave riders heaps of room downwind, when they crank their bottom turn you would be amazed at how quickly they shoot off downwind.

It's different at different places though, eg at coronations with no real defined break the guy jumping has right of way.

With windsurfers it's different anyway, because we can pass within a metre or two of each other and be quite safe. It's when there are 25 metre strings buzzing around that I start to get nervous (especially if I'm the one controlling them )

It all boils down to this:
The guy who is most manouverable should give way to the guy who is restricted in where he can be. That covers just about any situation.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
13 Oct 2010 11:31AM
Thumbs Up

cool I thought I was the only one going by my rules. Windsurfers not wanting to hit a peeling lip sound like a good reason for them to not be in the wrong spot when your on a wave. I actually got out yesterday and it didn't happen once.
And Get funky I was thinking here we go again when I read your post

KIT33R
NSW, 1716 posts
13 Oct 2010 4:05PM
Thumbs Up

I've been riding surfboards since 1968.
Only rule I've ever known is that the guy riding the wave has right of way.
What changed when you put a mast or a kite on the board?

sir ROWDY
WA, 5378 posts
13 Oct 2010 1:09PM
Thumbs Up

The only rule I know of is, if I am coming out and getting buck off a kicker get the **** outa my way.

p.s. Actually there is another one I know of to, if I am comming in on a wave on a surfboard get the **** outa my way.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
13 Oct 2010 2:10PM
Thumbs Up

Bring it on rowdy I have a shed of old kites to ditch right at you. And my shed is bigger than yours

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
13 Oct 2010 2:24PM
Thumbs Up

KIT33R said...
What changed when you put a mast or a kite on the board?


Wind.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
13 Oct 2010 3:02PM
Thumbs Up

TurtleHunter said...

cool I thought I was the only one going by my rules. Windsurfers not wanting to hit a peeling lip sound like a good reason for them to not be in the wrong spot when your on a wave. I actually got out yesterday and it didn't happen once.
And Get funky I was thinking here we go again when I read your post



Ha ha - fair nuf. I got a bit down the track on my spieal from the original thread;s direction.

Soap box returned.

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
13 Oct 2010 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

As a surfer, ex windsurfer and kitesurfer I think anyone on a decent wave has right of way, this is just out of consideration and Ill get right out of the way. This is because regardless of your sport, a good wave is hard to get on.
Windsurfers, again show consideration. They are underpowered and stall frequently whilst getting out because of the waves and currents and giving them a nice clean run to get over a wave is again just being considerate. And yes, most windsurfers are scared S***less when they are directly downwind passing a kitesurfer....keep your kite high...

sir ROWDY
WA, 5378 posts
13 Oct 2010 8:37PM
Thumbs Up

TurtleHunter said...

Bring it on rowdy I have a shed of old kites to ditch right at you. And my shed is bigger than yours


If by "shed" you mean "shelf" then yes I agree. But I still doubt you have more old kites, however, if you do once all my kites are used up I'm gonna be commin straight at ya with razor tipped windsurfers made before I even existed.

wishy
WA, 1501 posts
13 Oct 2010 10:08PM
Thumbs Up

On the way out through the surf I am always completely out of control and almost always 4-10m in the air. I usually close my eyes and hope noone gets hurt. Sorry if I have breached any right of way rules.

stoff
WA, 248 posts
13 Oct 2010 10:38PM
Thumbs Up

I only give way to newbies! They are the only ones that will
seriously f up your day! Everyone else seems to work it out
ok without having stupid rules to stick to!

graceful
WA, 773 posts
14 Oct 2010 2:18AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote


Er.. I've been watching too many eps of Breaking Bad.. yo.


Ahahahah
I just did 3 seasons in 2 days... I love that shi t Yo

Mr float
NSW, 3452 posts
14 Oct 2010 10:22AM
Thumbs Up

interesting comments .there seems to be a consensus here on this forum that if you are on a wave you have right of way and give way to noobies no matter what (which makes good sense) .It seems around here however the old poleys rule that if you are schlogging out in sub poling winds (or plenty of wind) you can head out straight through the riding zone and straight up the face becasue if you don't you won't get out ,and abuse any kiters on the wave riding down the line that even come close .I can understand and respect that to a degree (not the abuse tho) but when riders, (kiters and poleys ) sit on the shore and seem to line you up on the wave and go it is quite frustrating .

Gorgo
VIC, 5127 posts
14 Oct 2010 10:42AM
Thumbs Up

I don't understand the guy on the wave having right of way. They've usually got the most manouverability and can avoid anybody slogging out.

Whenever I encounter somebody on the way out I just do a turn under or over them. It's fun and makes me feel like a good rider.

There's no such thing as right of way. There's only the responsibility to avoid accidents and to avoid screwing up somebody else's day.

Mr float
NSW, 3452 posts
14 Oct 2010 10:59AM
Thumbs Up

Gorgo said...

I don't understand the guy on the wave having right of way. They've usually got the most manouverability and can avoid anybody slogging out.

Whenever I encounter somebody on the way out I just do a turn under or over them. It's fun and makes me feel like a good rider.

There's no such thing as right of way. There's only the responsibility to avoid accidents and to avoid screwing up somebody else's day.


I think someone here said it before ,when you are on a wave you are generally really concentrating on the wave .i know from my own personal experience this is really important when you are riding a reef break .One slip up and your smashed onto the reef . Agreed that if you are on a wave don't assume that you have the absolute right (just like the schloggers and their "absolute right") and it is good ettiquette to consider others particularly when you have the chance . Of course it is common sense to avoid collisions but my point is that the guy waiting on the beach could wait a moment longer for the dude on the wave who within a moment could be riding the critical section of the wave over the reef and not be able to "consider others " as much as usual or as others think they should .

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
14 Oct 2010 12:49PM
Thumbs Up

sir ROWDY said...

TurtleHunter said...

Bring it on rowdy I have a shed of old kites to ditch right at you. And my shed is bigger than yours


If by "shed" you mean "shelf" then yes I agree. But I still doubt you have more old kites, however, if you do once all my kites are used up I'm gonna be commin straight at ya with razor tipped windsurfers made before I even existed.

Load your truck and head over rowdy.[}:)] look out Indo there going to be a sh** load of kites drifting your way. I might even bring out the old pickle fork and make a rowdy fork.

sir ROWDY
WA, 5378 posts
14 Oct 2010 1:21PM
Thumbs Up

**** the pickle fork, I'm commin straight at ya with a Yipsee Wayler!!!

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
14 Oct 2010 5:48PM
Thumbs Up

what do you have a windsurfing museum or something

lotofwind
NSW, 6451 posts
15 Oct 2010 9:33PM
Thumbs Up

There is only a handfull of us that kite at our local.
If someone is on a wave shooting down the line,and one of us is heading out,the person heading out will do a few gybes in the shallows till the waverider has past.
You usually only have to gybe around for 5 seconds til they pass.That way you dont wreck someones wave.
Nothing worse than picking off a nice set wave and someone,who could have waited 2 seconds, shoots straight out in front of you.
A bit of common sence and respect goes along way.

hilly
WA, 8138 posts
15 Oct 2010 6:51PM
Thumbs Up

lotofwind said...

There is only a handfull of us that kite at our local.
If someone is on a wave shooting down the line,and one of us is heading out,the person heading out will do a few gybes in the shallows till the waverider has past.
You usually only have to gybe around for 5 seconds til they pass.That way you dont wreck someones wave.
Nothing worse than picking off a nice set wave and someone,who could have waited 2 seconds, shoots straight out in front of you.
A bit of common sence and respect goes along way.


Well said

Marcsurfs2
NSW, 9 posts
15 Oct 2010 10:40PM
Thumbs Up

Alright guys, WAVE SAILING RULES 101

Quoted from: www.windsurfwa.com/WA/rules.html

Sailing safely in waves requires adherence to a certain set of immutable rules. The wave riding rules are aimed at making wave riding safer and more enjoyable for all. They are largely taken from surfing rules, with some additions, applicable only to sailboards.

* Don't sail in conditions way out of your experience. Wave sailing requires a good water start (fast and efficient), preferably a reliable gybe (or tack), and probably the ability to jump. Don't sail conditions that are way out of your capabilities, you will just break gear and ruin the waves for everybody else (especially in crowded breaks).
* The sailor who is heading out has right of way of the sailor that is coming in on the wave. The sailor riding the wave has speed and maneuverability, and must give way to those sailing out.
* The sailor riding the wave closest to the breaking part of the wave has right of way over all other wave riders. Usually this is the sailor most upwind. You can ride a wave with a sailor closer to the breaking part of the wave than yourself, but don't crowd the sailor, and watch closely and be prepared to get out of the way.
* Don't drop in. This is a very bad practice, completely abhorred in surfing and windsurfing circles, and is very dangerous. Dropping in is the act of climbing on a wave that someone else is already riding. Dropping in is often achieved by sailing over the back of a wave that someone else is already riding. Doing this can lead to landing on top of the person riding the wave, and is thus dangerous. The first person on a wave, owns the wave.
* Don't ride shore-wards on the back of a wave. This practice is dangerous. In such a position you cannot see the sailors that are in the water until the last moment, and it is easy to hit them as the appear through the back of the wave.

These rules are universally accepted around the world. If you abide by them, you will have little trouble with other sailors in the waves. If you don't, you will have some very angry sailors confronting you on the beach.

terryzarmzof
QLD, 336 posts
15 Oct 2010 10:10PM
Thumbs Up

i say dont **** up a nice wave, if your heading back out take the pain bitch

Mr float
NSW, 3452 posts
15 Oct 2010 11:34PM
Thumbs Up

lotofwind said...

There is only a handfull of us that kite at our local.
If someone is on a wave shooting down the line,and one of us is heading out,the person heading out will do a few gybes in the shallows till the waverider has past.
You usually only have to gybe around for 5 seconds til they pass.That way you dont wreck someones wave.
Nothing worse than picking off a nice set wave and someone,who could have waited 2 seconds, shoots straight out in front of you.
A bit of common sence and respect goes along way.


nice



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"right of way in the surf" started by TurtleHunter