Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > Sailing General

What I know about Fuel Filters is not enough

Reply
Created by Concepcion > 9 months ago, 7 Aug 2017
Concepcion
SA, 93 posts
7 Aug 2017 9:41AM
Thumbs Up

So Im doing the usual winter service jobs - oil, gearbox, fuel filters, anodes, etc, and I run into a problem. After replacement, the primary CAV fuel filter/ water separater won't fill. I try everything, fuel primer, blow return, suck via secondary, but nothing. Check fuel entering top of primary filter housing, obviously fuel on & fuel moving...but it quickly fills breather cap, without entering filter or bowl - huh? I check for air gaps or other pressure in system and nothing I get x4 of the club's brains trust on the job and still no result. I reassemble old filter (which was remarkably clean!) and it immediately fills and after bleeding/ priming secondary filter and injectors with fuel engine starts & works fine. Only explanation is a faulty fuel filter...but i replaced like with like - even used the old rubber seals when checking.

System is a standard type with clear bowl DELPHI 7111-296 filter - Engine is Kabuto/Beta marine BD1005

Any Advice appreciated.

Bruski068
VIC, 457 posts
7 Aug 2017 11:31AM
Thumbs Up

Is there a seal on the top of the filter that needs removing before installation?

fishmonkey
NSW, 494 posts
7 Aug 2017 12:52PM
Thumbs Up

if you definitely had all the right seals in place then i would try another filter...

grich62
QLD, 678 posts
7 Aug 2017 3:50PM
Thumbs Up

these filter set ups are the worst filter ever made,they will leak air into them every time you fit a filter kit.make sure that the 2 large o rings are in the correct spots 1 is slightly larger than the other,the larger one goes on the bowel to filter connection,do not use grease to hold them in place as when you tighten it may slip and leak air also make sure the bolt has a new seal and the top o,ring is in place take the whole filter of and assemble it upside down taking care to mate o,ring seal .there are also 2 different seal kits available 1 has o,rings and 1 has square o,rings ,make sure your kit is exactly the same as what came out.once you are sure it is assembled right vacuum test it for leaks . also if it is fitted before the lift pump it can take a while to bleed all air out,if it is fitted after bleed it at the filter .investing in a spin on filter is my advise as think how hard this is to do in a big sea under stress no eng floating towards some rocks.

Concepcion
SA, 93 posts
7 Aug 2017 4:10PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Bruski, fishmonkey and grich - thanks for advice. Couldn't agree more with the filter 'design' comment. Easy to remove but a bugga to reassemble & bleed (yes my lift pump is approx 2m and vertical of prime filter). I've consulted another mechanic who has suggested it is likely an air pocket in filter assembly/ pressure. Failure can occur in seals (ships, I didn't realise the bowl seal was the larger one!) yet, I can't understand how as: 1-no fuel leaked when assembled, even after I attempted to pre-fill (yes a very messy experience & I'm sure no seal blockage on filter).
So grich it looks like I need a spin on filter - any that you could recommend for 28hp Beta - interested in cost effectiveness here.

Trek
NSW, 1215 posts
7 Aug 2017 5:32PM
Thumbs Up

I hate to be the bull in the China shop but I like that exact filter and have used them often! But they are a trick to put together.

Maybe the input / out ports on the top are mixed up?

Ramona
NSW, 7757 posts
7 Aug 2017 5:45PM
Thumbs Up

I've used those filters for years. They are fine if you have easy access to like in a trawler engine room but hard to assemble laying on your side working across a yachts "engine room". I'm about to toss mine, I'm sure it's a source of an air leak. I'm assured by my mate these are the go. They are not real Racor's but good enough.
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Fuel-Filter-Water-Turbine-Diesel-Biodiesel-Separator-500FG-Brand-New/182504779037?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649

radar
NSW, 86 posts
7 Aug 2017 6:50PM
Thumbs Up

sounds like one of the ports in the filter head hasnt been drilled properly

woko
NSW, 1802 posts
7 Aug 2017 7:22PM
Thumbs Up

I've got a similar tale of reliability with the cav type filters, in a great arangment of machines. There can be a difference in seal kits and as Ramona suggest if access if is tight they can be a trial to assemble, if the old filter worked on refit then my guess is that the filter is bodgy. Unless there's a sneaky oring stuck on your old unit that hasn't come with the new kit ?

dreamliner
NSW, 110 posts
7 Aug 2017 9:04PM
Thumbs Up

Cant say Ive had any issues using them over the years , you did fill the new filter up with fresh fuel before screwing back on ??

grich62
QLD, 678 posts
7 Aug 2017 9:19PM
Thumbs Up

Ramona said..
I've used those filters for years. They are fine if you have easy access to like in a trawler engine room but hard to assemble laying on your side working across a yachts "engine room". I'm about to toss mine, I'm sure it's a source of an air leak. I'm assured by my mate these are the go. They are not real Racor's but good enough.
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Fuel-Filter-Water-Turbine-Diesel-Biodiesel-Separator-500FG-Brand-New/182504779037?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649


ok guys i don,t want to get in to fight ,but the 500fg requires a lot fuel flow to make the turbine work they are designed for high flow fuel systems on high power engines so not the ideal filter for replacing the cav filter .they also suffer from over tightening and can leak at the top .also be aware of non return valves in the filter head. i often use a oil evacuation pump to prime a hard system and they will show up a air leak around the filter .most times you can get spin on fuel filter heads from a marine shop just make sure you get a diesel filter to fit, stemco also make good filter sets to suit .if it is mounted to the engine you will need room to remove.remember that you are not filtering lots of fuel so you don,t need a big filter . if your filter is mounted high in the engine room it will be even harder to get the fuel from the tank down to the pump so use the oil evacuation pump to help bleed . while using the pump you can find any blockages or collapsing fuel lines (cheap auto fuel line is for pressure not vacuum not for boats )

grich62
QLD, 678 posts
7 Aug 2017 9:39PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Concepcion said..
Hi Bruski, fishmonkey and grich - thanks for advice. Couldn't agree more with the filter 'design' comment. Easy to remove but a bugga to reassemble & bleed (yes my lift pump is approx 2m and vertical of prime filter). I've consulted another mechanic who has suggested it is likely an air pocket in filter assembly/ pressure. Failure can occur in seals (ships, I didn't realise the bowl seal was the larger one!) yet, I can't understand how as: 1-no fuel leaked when assembled, even after I attempted to pre-fill (yes a very messy experience & I'm sure no seal blockage on filter).
So grich it looks like I need a spin on filter - any that you could recommend for 28hp Beta - interested in cost effectiveness here.


cav filters and delphy filters are 2 different designs make sure you have the correct designed filter for your brand. looking at the photo it does not look fitted right the bottom o,ring looks set to one side and the top appears in to much is there a o,ring fitted between filter and the housing .you can get small cheap vac pumps from most shops,it was the only way i could start a gen set on a mariatimo that had run out of fuel,its prime pump had no chance of sucking fuel the 5 meters back to the genset

Ramona
NSW, 7757 posts
8 Aug 2017 7:53AM
Thumbs Up

grich62 said..

Ramona said..
I've used those filters for years. They are fine if you have easy access to like in a trawler engine room but hard to assemble laying on your side working across a yachts "engine room". I'm about to toss mine, I'm sure it's a source of an air leak. I'm assured by my mate these are the go. They are not real Racor's but good enough.
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Fuel-Filter-Water-Turbine-Diesel-Biodiesel-Separator-500FG-Brand-New/182504779037?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649



ok guys i don,t want to get in to fight ,but the 500fg requires a lot fuel flow to make the turbine work they are designed for high flow fuel systems on high power engines so not the ideal filter for replacing the cav filter .they also suffer from over tightening and can leak at the top .also be aware of non return valves in the filter head. i often use a oil evacuation pump to prime a hard system and they will show up a air leak around the filter .most times you can get spin on fuel filter heads from a marine shop just make sure you get a diesel filter to fit, stemco also make good filter sets to suit .if it is mounted to the engine you will need room to remove.remember that you are not filtering lots of fuel so you don,t need a big filter . if your filter is mounted high in the engine room it will be even harder to get the fuel from the tank down to the pump so use the oil evacuation pump to help bleed . while using the pump you can find any blockages or collapsing fuel lines (cheap auto fuel line is for pressure not vacuum not for boats )


Thanks for the heads up on fuel flow and getting the turbine to work. Mate has one on his Perkins so I will have to check that.

Jolene
WA, 1624 posts
8 Aug 2017 7:05AM
Thumbs Up

This is the vac tester and catch can I have and use. Vacuum leaks in the fueling system can be hard to find as quite often air will be getting drawn in but no fuel will be leaking out. I have also found that pressurizing the system will sometimes not diagnose the problem.

Concepcion
SA, 93 posts
8 Aug 2017 11:41AM
Thumbs Up

thank you seabreezers - so many good ideas here - learning by doing!

grich62
QLD, 678 posts
8 Aug 2017 12:50PM
Thumbs Up

Ramona said..

grich62 said..


Ramona said..
I've used those filters for years. They are fine if you have easy access to like in a trawler engine room but hard to assemble laying on your side working across a yachts "engine room". I'm about to toss mine, I'm sure it's a source of an air leak. I'm assured by my mate these are the go. They are not real Racor's but good enough.
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/Fuel-Filter-Water-Turbine-Diesel-Biodiesel-Separator-500FG-Brand-New/182504779037?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649




ok guys i don,t want to get in to fight ,but the 500fg requires a lot fuel flow to make the turbine work they are designed for high flow fuel systems on high power engines so not the ideal filter for replacing the cav filter .they also suffer from over tightening and can leak at the top .also be aware of non return valves in the filter head. i often use a oil evacuation pump to prime a hard system and they will show up a air leak around the filter .most times you can get spin on fuel filter heads from a marine shop just make sure you get a diesel filter to fit, stemco also make good filter sets to suit .if it is mounted to the engine you will need room to remove.remember that you are not filtering lots of fuel so you don,t need a big filter . if your filter is mounted high in the engine room it will be even harder to get the fuel from the tank down to the pump so use the oil evacuation pump to help bleed . while using the pump you can find any blockages or collapsing fuel lines (cheap auto fuel line is for pressure not vacuum not for boats )



Thanks for the heads up on fuel flow and getting the turbine to work. Mate has one on his Perkins so I will have to check that.


the filter will still work but the moisture will only bleed of the paper.not from the spin affect of the design . some of the 4 wd places have some good filter systems.
ok just for any one that are interested if people want to sell you any fuel additives or stabilizers that claim to remove water from your fuel tank ,it is only making the water stay suspended in the fuel and passing it through the filter into the fuel pump and injectors to be burnt with the fuel, these are the bits you are trying to stop moisture getting to so be warned .i had 1 bloke tell me that it separated the water in to hydrogen and oxygen to make the engine run better !! (snake oil).



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"What I know about Fuel Filters is not enough" started by Concepcion