Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > Windsurfing General

Aerodynamics for the gullible

Reply
Created by nebbian > 9 months ago, 6 Apr 2008
nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
6 Apr 2008 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

http://www.oceanrodeo.com/kiting/images/rise/RiseVenturiExplained2.swf



NJPornstar
WA, 790 posts
7 Apr 2008 1:13AM
Thumbs Up

Yeh right,
Wouldnt it go around in circles when it comes outta the vent.....

P.C_simpson
WA, 1492 posts
7 Apr 2008 8:50AM
Thumbs Up

so ocean rodeo obviously have not herd of the slot fin or seen a few experimental sails from the old speed sailing era, guess what they didn't work, and i think the plane designers of the last say, 60 years would have thought of this and be using it now. another gimick for the kite would to spend there money on..

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
7 Apr 2008 11:07AM
Thumbs Up

I put one of those vents in my sail yesterday! While sailing (well, crashing)

grumplestiltskin
WA, 2331 posts
7 Apr 2008 9:13AM
Thumbs Up

before you are allowed to purchase and use this kite, you must be prepared to wear this outfit.

slowboat
WA, 560 posts
7 Apr 2008 11:12AM
Thumbs Up

"booster pipes"

Richiefish
QLD, 5612 posts
7 Apr 2008 7:09PM
Thumbs Up

some kind of super hero flying fetish thing I suspect....?

kitecrazzzy
WA, 2184 posts
7 Apr 2008 6:44PM
Thumbs Up

if that was true then wouldnt the normal kite pull most when at the top of the window?
truth is the venturi effect does not happen any more with 08 kites unless you want it to and I personally use all the kite phenomenons to my advantage like reverse launching and pivot turns and would be uynhappy for my kite to not be able to do that as im not a kook who needs a kite that flys itself.

sflack
VIC, 574 posts
7 Apr 2008 8:59PM
Thumbs Up

kitecrazzzy said...

if that was true then wouldnt the normal kite pull most when at the top of the window?
truth is the venturi effect does not happen any more with 08 kites unless you want it to and I personally use all the kite phenomenons to my advantage like reverse launching and pivot turns and would be uynhappy for my kite to not be able to do that as im not a kook who needs a kite that flys itself.


...HUH?

MintoxGT
WA, 975 posts
7 Apr 2008 7:15PM
Thumbs Up

grumplestiltskin said...

before you are allowed to purchase and use this kite, you must be prepared to wear this outfit.




I would also be wearing a full face visor

MavericK040
WA, 583 posts
7 Apr 2008 7:33PM
Thumbs Up

wheather or not that idea works on kites i dont care but , they do use slotted flaps on planes like the 747 and a whole variety of other types of planes.
they let the wing take on a higher angle of attack without stalling on takeoff and landing.

just like in the picture as the wing reaches critical AOA usually about 16 degrees the boundary layer breaks away from the surface of the wing and it stalls ,
so what the slot does is to keep laminar flow all the way along the chord of the wing at high angles of attack and low speeds usually the flow breaks away further down the chord first which is why the slots are at the back!

so yes!! aircraft designers have been and will still be using this technology for some time.


and WTF is with the outfit ? who would seriously wear such a thing

Gybesports
NSW, 193 posts
8 Apr 2008 2:29PM
Thumbs Up

I agree with Maverick. It doesn't work on a slot fin because the angle of attack and speed is wrong but it might work on a kite at high angle and slow speeds! Just like on a 747 landing.

We will see!!

slowboat
WA, 560 posts
8 Apr 2008 12:36PM
Thumbs Up

A properly designed slot delays the point at which flow separation migrates forward (the beginning of stall). This is due to the slot "refreshing" the boundary layer and reducing the adverse pressure gradient over that last section- so the boundary layer doesnt have to "push as hard" for "as far". Result is higher angles of attack before the lift breaks down and the drag slope increases.

Flow separation can occur in either laminar flow or turbulent flow conditions. Trailing edge separation will be turbulent flow separation for typical foils.

For this to be useful, the slot shape is critical, since flow separation can occur immediately if the downstream side of the slot is made too sharp.

So if its not done right, the result will be less lift and more drag, giving no advantage at higher angles of attack (where its meant to work) compared to a partially stalled regular section.

The main benefit of this technology in aircrafts is to significantly increase the wing camber with highly angled flaps. This increases the amount of lift for a given angle of attack. Without the slots, the separated flow would render the flaps significantly less effective.

If it aint done right...

jp747
1553 posts
8 Apr 2008 10:28PM
Thumbs Up

in the near future one of the better sail makers would have vented slots with sort of springs to vent out 1-2sec. gusts so the rider maintains posistion and not lose speed...does that seem logical

NotWal
QLD, 7436 posts
9 Apr 2008 12:02PM
Thumbs Up

jp747 said...

in the near future one of the better sail makers would have vented slots with sort of springs to vent out 1-2sec. gusts so the rider maintains posistion and not lose speed...does that seem logical


Isn't that what twist does?
The vents they put in wings are there to stop stalling at slow speeds and high angles of attack. In a sail they might help your pumping and low end grunt I would expect.

jp747
1553 posts
9 Apr 2008 7:36PM
Thumbs Up

NotWal said...

jp747 said...

in the near future one of the better sail makers would have vented slots with sort of springs to vent out 1-2sec. gusts so the rider maintains posistion and not lose speed...does that seem logical


Isn't that what twist does?
The vents they put in wings are there to stop stalling at slow speeds and high angles of attack. In a sail they might help your pumping and low end grunt I would expect.


i guess i put to mind the older versions of the rs5 where the twist was about the whole top half of the sail and they came back with the rs6 with just the right opening..also i wanted to visualise the vents on the middle part of the sail and adjust at particular gusts..true the twist on all sails do help but when it really gusts in bunches even AA has to compensate...am just blabbering notwali wish i was top 20 in the world in any discipline then i could say something more unrubbish

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
10 Apr 2008 10:42AM
Thumbs Up

I have a slotted fin and i love it. I use it on Botany Bay in big southerlies when the fin spends as much time out of the water as it does in. This thing recovers from spin out almost before it happens.

Maybe the problems in the past with vented sails has been the implementation of the theory, rather than the theory itself?

Sure twisting sails are designed to absorb gusts, but doesn't mean that it can't be done another way. Maybe there could also be a reduction of turbulence or drag that could push past that 50knot barrier?

Anyway, I think we should embrace any innovative ideas (even when they are a rehash of old ideas). Progression of technology is about science, but also about experimentation and just plain old dumb luck. Sometimes new concepts are discovered by accident by doing something "stupid".

evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
10 Apr 2008 10:53AM
Thumbs Up

Harrow said...


Maybe the problems in the past with vented sails has been the implementation of the theory, rather than the theory itself?


Yup, have been wondering that about the resurgence/reintroduction of twin fins, and the obvious lack of thrusters. Is there a technical reason why thrusters (3 fins) don't work on windsurfers or has it just been poor/unlucky implementation?

nebbian
WA, 6277 posts
10 Apr 2008 10:22AM
Thumbs Up

evlPanda said...



Yup, have been wondering that about the resurgence/reintroduction of twin fins, and the obvious lack of thrusters. Is there a technical reason why thrusters (3 fins) don't work on windsurfers or has it just been poor/unlucky implementation?



I think that Mr. Stone (of SSD) might disagree with you

NotWal
QLD, 7436 posts
10 Apr 2008 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

Harrow said...

I have a slotted fin and i love it. I use it on Botany Bay in big southerlies when the fin spends as much time out of the water as it does in. This thing recovers from spin out almost before it happens.

Maybe the problems in the past with vented sails has been the implementation of the theory, rather than the theory itself?

Sure twisting sails are designed to absorb gusts, but doesn't mean that it can't be done another way. Maybe there could also be a reduction of turbulence or drag that could push past that 50knot barrier?

Anyway, I think we should embrace any innovative ideas (even when they are a rehash of old ideas). Progression of technology is about science, but also about experimentation and just plain old dumb luck. Sometimes new concepts are discovered by accident by doing something "stupid".


I used to ride a slotted fin. It was undersized but it didn't matter because, as you say, it recovered from spin out so easily. hmmm... maybe they'd be good for freestyle

You are also right about accidental empirical discovery. So much of what we take for granted is the result of that - penicillin, stainless steel, and sail twist (credited to Bruce Peterson when they were testing rigs by fixing them on a vehicle and measuring their lift and drag. He started poking at the head of the sail with a stick and watched the numbers react)

So when you cut some slots in your sail and test it Harrow, we expect you to report back and tell us how it went.

jp747
1553 posts
10 Apr 2008 6:30PM
Thumbs Up

why isn't there any move to put some drag reduction devices on the top if the board itself..everything i bet was tested underneath but on top am sure just in 20kts of speed there is wind drag in front, mastbase,footstraps and etc..nobody ever tried putting some sort of spoilers to push the front end down..however, not all of this was thought for wave riding and freestyle..it'd be

mrrt
WA, 72 posts
13 Apr 2008 8:42PM
Thumbs Up

Harrow said...

I have a slotted fin and i love it. I use it on Botany Bay in big southerlies when the fin spends as much time out of the water as it does in. This thing recovers from spin out almost before it happens.


Yeah, I used to have quite a few slotted fins years ago and yes, they did indeed delay spinout amazingly, and aid recovery as well.

Unfortunately they also caused a lot more drag and were thus significantly slower than my other fins, hence why I gave them up and went for flex tip fins in the waves and deeper pointer fins for slalom.

Basically, I can't see slots being used in high speed scenarios - after all, airliners only extend their slotted flaps during landing to improve lift at slow speed when extra drag is actually welcome to help slow the aircraft. They retract the flaps and close the slots at higher speeds.

My 2c

-Mart



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Aerodynamics for the gullible" started by nebbian