Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > Windsurfing General

windsurfing vs kitesurfing

Reply
Created by hjnks > 9 months ago, 7 Mar 2012
hjnks
2 posts
7 Mar 2012 6:45PM
Thumbs Up

gday all, im thinking about getting into the sport, i was wondering whether i should consider kitesurfing. ive been youtubing a fair bit and im a little more drawn to windsurfing. i would just like to get the windsurfing community to pitch in what their thoughts on the two sports are to help me make this crucial decision. thanks hope to see you on the water soon

Donk
NSW, 390 posts
7 Mar 2012 9:51PM
Thumbs Up

Done both but the biggest stoke for me was wavesailing. I had fun kiting though but can't afford both sports. Kids will do that to you

joe windsurf
1482 posts
7 Mar 2012 7:10PM
Thumbs Up

hope you asked the same question on the kite surf forum

comes down to cost, like the donk said, space for storage, and transport
windsurf stuff takes space
i believe that dollar for dollar the sports are similiar
i have been told that kitesurfing is a little "easier"

in real estate they say location, location, location
where you plan to go - wind, waves, setup area , etc all count

lessons for kiting are more available than windsurfing - where i come from as well

if you can try windsurfing - the first try is easier in this sport - in lite winds

as long as either one gets you on the water with a smile = life is good
on this forum we will be biased towards kitesurfing of course

joewindsurfer.blogspot.com/p/how-you-can-start-windsurfing.html

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
7 Mar 2012 10:35PM
Thumbs Up

According to Wikopedia kitesurfing is akin checkers and windsurfing is akin chess. That is as good an analogy as any.

tjsports
40 posts
7 Mar 2012 7:38PM
Thumbs Up

A guy in QLD died kite surfing last weekend. He was a learner. I think a few kiters have died. I don't think I have seen that a sail boarder has died any time recently.

echunda
VIC, 765 posts
7 Mar 2012 11:08PM
Thumbs Up

Piss off troll..


You've posted in every forum to stir up ****.....



Go post up on 4chan if you want to talk junk..

ggh
VIC, 190 posts
8 Mar 2012 11:34AM
Thumbs Up

A few years ago when I returned to Aus after a stint in the UK I decided as I could not aford a moth sailing dingy ( just been married ) thought I would give kite surfing a go. It looked fantastic and seemed easer than havng to re-learn gybing ect . However the" just being married "and buying new home really kicked in and it was apparent i couldnt afford a Kite either . So I went round to my mums house and dusted of the old winsdurfing gear I had circa 1990 and just went sailing with the intention to kite later when housing deposits ect where under control.

Finallly got a couple of Kite lessons and thats when I realised the fundermental differance. Kiteing is wake boarding with a Kite for power . Windsurfing is sailing .

As I want to sail as i have done since I was a kid in a sabot I have stuck with. winsurfing. And loving every minute .

If I had enough money and Time i would own both and a moth and 49er and chuck in a f18 for good measure

WindmanV
VIC, 826 posts
8 Mar 2012 1:11PM
Thumbs Up

Reply by a windsurfer.

Kitesurfing: more cost-effective, less load space in a car, easier to learn, beach-space intensive, substantially more dangerous than windsurfing (Google hurt kite surfer).

Windsurfing: gear and cost-intensive, high load space in car, harder to learn to turn, less beach space, substantially less injuries than kitesurfing.

Was at Rickett's Point last night and it was a pleasure to watch one of the kiters doing spectacular jumps and being in control whilst high in the air in the 20kt + wind.

Fun factor of both sports is high.

echunda
VIC, 765 posts
8 Mar 2012 1:22PM
Thumbs Up

echunda said...

Piss off troll..


You've posted in every forum to stir up ****.....



Go post up on 4chan if you want to talk junk..


Sorry,

Had my angry shorts on last night.

If you are truly asking as a newby I apologise....

If your starting trouble I take the apolgy back.

boardboy
QLD, 554 posts
8 Mar 2012 3:10PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Hjnks,

mate id recomend you try both and see which one you like. Its a personel preference thing and the only persons whose opinion matters is your own.

Good luck! I hope you find the sport you are gonna love!

jsnfok
WA, 899 posts
8 Mar 2012 9:36PM
Thumbs Up

dont do either if you fancy your money to stay in your account

esku
17 posts
16 Mar 2012 6:19AM
Thumbs Up

I start windsurfing at 1973/4, I start kitesurfing something like 15 years ago and quit WS, now I am back to WS and quit KS.
I was a WS and a KS instructor.
I can find a lot of similarity in both and a big different as well.
The guy that mention that WS is sailing and KS is not, he is right.
You can see it even with the people that do each sport.
Most of WS guys knows about the tech behind the gear and all around.
Most of KS guys don't know even how the kite fly or pull, they just Ksurf and does it good.
Try both and do what you like best, I love both.

Mark _australia
WA, 23711 posts
16 Mar 2012 8:14AM
Thumbs Up

So Hjnks have you gone back and looked at your other thread? It is up to 4 pages now.

Or has all the bickering in that one prompted you to try again?

Leelo
WA, 23 posts
16 Mar 2012 2:44PM
Thumbs Up

Driving a car without lessons is dangerous. In fact look how many P platers die each year.

Forget all the negative talk about you may die, Sh1t you might die driving to work.

Whichever sport you choose, get proper lessons, and dont go out by yourself until you are fully competent(that is competent not confidant). I am a Kiter and yes have had some dodgy situations thrown upon me with unexpected gusts and all sorts. But I had the proper instruction so I could react to the situation and keep myself alive(thus far).

Its like asking should I like olives. Some people do, some dont, they dont know what you will or wont like. They will just tell you what they like.

Get a lesson in both and see which one appeals to you. End of Story.

oldie
VIC, 356 posts
19 Mar 2012 12:26AM
Thumbs Up

Kight Fright!
You never know who will drop in ..

hoop
1979 posts
18 Mar 2012 9:40PM
Thumbs Up

"Should I like olives? " How the fLIck did you come up with that one?

pierrec45
NSW, 2005 posts
19 Mar 2012 6:08AM
Thumbs Up

hjnks said...

gday all (...) i was wondering whether

There's a topic in the "General" that seems to imply it's a choice, can't remember exactly which...

Anyways, if they're right, then try them both !

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
19 Mar 2012 8:21AM
Thumbs Up

hjnks said...

gday all, im thinking about getting into the sport, i was wondering whether i should consider kitesurfing. ive been youtubing a fair bit and im a little more drawn to windsurfing. i would just like to get the windsurfing community to pitch in what their thoughts on the two sports are to help me make this crucial decision. thanks hope to see you on the water soon


Windsurfing is a pain in the a$$ to get good at, possibly a few months before you can get going on a short board (depends on how much you sail), I learned to kite in 3 days. So in the short term, probably kiting. But windsurfing is more rewarding and challenging, so if you are willing to persevere then give windsurfing a shot.

ginger pom
VIC, 1746 posts
20 Mar 2012 8:26AM
Thumbs Up

Zed said...

Windsurfing is a pain in the a$$ to get good at, possibly a few months before you can get going on a short board (depends on how much you sail), I learned to kite in 3 days. So in the short term, probably kiting. But windsurfing is more rewarding and challenging, so if you are willing to persevere then give windsurfing a shot.


I've heard the same thing. Most windsurfers can learn to kite in 20 knots in around three to five days (I know of several mates who've done this and some have then gone back to windsurfing). Most kiters will take at least three months to learn to waterstart with a rig.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
20 Mar 2012 8:30AM
Thumbs Up

Zed said...


Windsurfing is a pain in the a$$ to get good at....



Don't you mean ar$e?



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"windsurfing vs kitesurfing" started by hjnks