Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Who got hail damage?

Reply
Created by doggie > 9 months ago, 22 Mar 2010
tightlines
WA, 3510 posts
24 Mar 2010 10:21PM
Thumbs Up

getfunky said...

^^^^ Spencer Tunic's latest work??


Good call, there is a strange similarity.

seafever17
WA, 360 posts
24 Mar 2010 11:02PM
Thumbs Up

you guys must mean dispense your tunic.

tightlines
WA, 3510 posts
25 Mar 2010 8:13AM
Thumbs Up

^ Ha ha another good call
www.spencertunick.com/

dirtyharry
WA, 444 posts
25 Mar 2010 2:00PM
Thumbs Up

Does anyone work in insurance?

My car is insured for $22k. It got peppered with little dents all over roof, bonnet and to a lesser extent doors etc.

It's got full comp insurance. I'm assuming that if the repair bill is >$22k they'll write it off, <$22k they'll fix it.

What I'm wondering is will they negotiate on this with me? Say the repair quote is $18k, could I suggest something like they give me $12k and I keep the dents? Sounds like a win-win to me - I get $12k (and a dented car which doesn't worry me too much for the sake of $12k!!) and they're $6k better off. Has anyone tried this?

Also, if it's a write off, will I get first offer on purchasing it back?

Thanks.

FormulaNova
WA, 15111 posts
25 Mar 2010 5:26PM
Thumbs Up

dirtyharry said...

Does anyone work in insurance?

My car is insured for $22k. It got peppered with little dents all over roof, bonnet and to a lesser extent doors etc.

It's got full comp insurance. I'm assuming that if the repair bill is >$22k they'll write it off, <$22k they'll fix it.

What I'm wondering is will they negotiate on this with me? Say the repair quote is $18k, could I suggest something like they give me $12k and I keep the dents? Sounds like a win-win to me - I get $12k (and a dented car which doesn't worry me too much for the sake of $12k!!) and they're $6k better off. Has anyone tried this?

Also, if it's a write off, will I get first offer on purchasing it back?

Thanks.



I don't work in insurance but I have had family members that did.

My take on this is that they will write it off if it has less than 22k worth of damage, unless they dislike you, think it is fraudulent, or that they can't recover the difference selling it as a wreck. Is it insured agreed value or market value?

I have heard stories of assessors recognising dents from a ball-pein hammer versus hailstones and refusing on that basis.

I have also heard of some particular insurance companies not settling even if the repair bill is the same as the value of the car.

The one thing they wont do is reinsure the car unless the damage is repaired, which makes sense.

I guess you can always ask them. They may be more willing to do this as they will have a heap of cars to fix.

dirtyharry
WA, 444 posts
25 Mar 2010 6:09PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks FN.

Not sure if agreed market value - but I only got (and insured) it about 3 months ago so assume it'll be alright either way.

I understand they won't fully comp re-insure it with the damage existing - but if I kept the dents/bought the car back, do you reckon I'd be able to get someone to give me 3rd party only insurance (I'd be happy with that under this scenario)?

Just seems logical to me that we come to some arrangement given the cost to them to repair it or pay it out (which they're obliged to do), and given that the dents don;t really bother me that much.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Who got hail damage?" started by doggie