Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > Kitesurfing General

Another Shark Attack?

Reply
Created by tightlines > 9 months ago, 11 Oct 2011
tightlines
WA, 3510 posts
11 Oct 2011 1:09AM
Thumbs Up

Looks like there may have been another attack.
Condolences to family and friends if this is the case.

www.abc.net.au/news/2011-10-10/missing-swimmer-shark-attack/3460948?section=wa

myusernam
QLD, 6160 posts
11 Oct 2011 8:25AM
Thumbs Up

poor guy.

you guys have a serious problem in WA. You can bash it up your arse.

And it's not less dangerous than riding in a car, dying from a bee etc. What they do with those statistics is sum every person in the world that swims in the ocean divided by the number of attacks or that are killed by bees...

What you need to do is say to yourself "if I go swimming at dawn/ dusk or after dark at cactus beach, or cottesloe or fraser/stradbroke island or in a seal colony off port lincoln, are my chances still less than being killed by a bee?" NOPE

So all you Wa guys hang onto whichever statistic makes you feel better. some guy from norway who swims in a sharkless ocean a few times a year definatley does have less of a chance of being eaten than you guys on that 'one last run' out wide when you line/uni/ fin fails...

default
WA, 1255 posts
11 Oct 2011 8:23AM
Thumbs Up

myusernam said...


you guys have a serious problem in WA. You can bash it up your arse.

........

So all you Wa guys hang onto whichever statistic makes you feel better.


wtf

default
WA, 1255 posts
11 Oct 2011 8:34AM
Thumbs Up

yeah tighty, looks like it may be the case.

sad... condolences to the family and friends, rip.

its that time of year again when whiteys come in to meet the whales migrating south with their calfs - many more around than usual this time of year. The whale migrations extend into december.

be careful out there... especially learners body dragging around.

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
11 Oct 2011 9:27AM
Thumbs Up

I've been surfing windsurfing, fishing etc for 20 odd years in WA and have seen a lot of sharks, big ones, not too far off the coast. Yet you often see swimmers, 500m, 1km etc off the coast swimming around, not a care in the world.. as this guy was. I'm not sure if it's ignorance or bravado...

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
11 Oct 2011 9:31AM
Thumbs Up

myusernam said...

poor guy.

you guys have a serious problem in WA. You can bash it up your arse.

And it's not less dangerous than riding in a car, dying from a bee etc. What they do with those statistics is sum every person in the world that swims in the ocean divided by the number of attacks or that are killed by bees...

What you need to do is say to yourself "if I go swimming at dawn/ dusk or after dark at cactus beach, or cottesloe or fraser/stradbroke island or in a seal colony off port lincoln, are my chances still less than being killed by a bee?" NOPE

So all you Wa guys hang onto whichever statistic makes you feel better. some guy from norway who swims in a sharkless ocean a few times a year definatley does have less of a chance of being eaten than you guys on that 'one last run' out wide when you line/uni/ fin fails...




stop smoking those men o war's retard .

harry potter
VIC, 2777 posts
11 Oct 2011 2:16PM
Thumbs Up

Condolences to the family............

Not really suprising though.......
This time of year
Several hundred metres off shore,
early morning
COTTESLOE beach !! ( that place must be like a shark drivethrough )

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
11 Oct 2011 11:32AM
Thumbs Up

Zed said...

I've been surfing windsurfing, fishing etc for 20 odd years in WA and have seen a lot of sharks, big ones, not too far off the coast. Yet you often see swimmers, 500m, 1km etc off the coast swimming around, not a care in the world.. as this guy was. I'm not sure if it's ignorance or bravado...

wasn't this guy only swimming out to the pylon.

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
11 Oct 2011 11:52AM
Thumbs Up

TurtleHunter said...

Zed said...

I've been surfing windsurfing, fishing etc for 20 odd years in WA and have seen a lot of sharks, big ones, not too far off the coast. Yet you often see swimmers, 500m, 1km etc off the coast swimming around, not a care in the world.. as this guy was. I'm not sure if it's ignorance or bravado...

wasn't this guy only swimming out to the pylon.



The article I read, said he swam past the pylon and then carried out another 500m out to sea.

Me and a mate were out on our surf-skis last summer just off Swanbourne (about a 1km) and a very large shark (bull or whitey) went cruising past, not giving us a second glance. We paddled in told the SLS and also a group of swimmers heading into the ocean, who smiled, waved us off dismissively and swam off into the distance.

natemarshall
WA, 93 posts
11 Oct 2011 2:48PM
Thumbs Up

i think if the shark is within 500m of the shore we have the right to kill it. the great white is a protected animal and now that they have learnt that they are safe in our waters they are going to stay here and not leave us alone.

my dad told me about this thing. it was where there were about 100 great whites surrounding an island off whales. then a killer whale grabbed one by the stomach and drowned it because it couldnt move. after that all of the greatwhites moved. they had a tracker on one of them and it dove down 500m and swam for hawawi

Radman
WA, 629 posts
11 Oct 2011 2:53PM
Thumbs Up

I Think ive said this before ,its time to do some thing about about this little problem, how bout all the do gooder shark lovers,fishery ministers,and people who arnt scared of gw there get out there and berly up and have a little swim with your lovely sharks maybe suppress there apitite for a while, and the rest of us can go on enjoying the beach.i feel some red thumbs coming on that fish has been hanging around for weeks tell me it hasnt got a taste for it

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
11 Oct 2011 3:23PM
Thumbs Up

On the plus side, my local is 2km out to sea, and every year there are fewer and fewer kiters So although I'm not that keen on windsurfing with sharks, they keep the kiters away [}:)]

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
11 Oct 2011 3:26PM
Thumbs Up

Radman said...
that fish has been hanging around for weeks tell me it hasnt got a taste for it

being a shark expert do you have evidence that this shark , which hasn't even been spotted has been hanging around as you say ?

Please inform this "shark lover" how you came to your well informed decision .

swinginginthewind
WA, 281 posts
11 Oct 2011 3:33PM
Thumbs Up

Zed said...

On the plus side, my local is 2km out to sea, and every year there are fewer and fewer kiters So although I'm not that keen on windsurfing with sharks, they keep the kiters away [}:)]


Hey Zed,

that spot 2kms off shore is a good break in the right conditions, kite out there myself sometimes.

Got talking with the fishing charter guys on one of the boats from the marina, reckons there's a big female GW that calls that area home.

That said I have also dived out there a fair bit and have only seen reef sharks in some of the caves.

stuntnaz
NSW, 540 posts
11 Oct 2011 7:09PM
Thumbs Up

WE ARE ALL KILLING THE PLANET AND HALF THE WORLD'S WILDLIFE IS GOING INTO EXTINCTION WERE RUNNING OUT OF FOREST 'S SO WHY NOT TAKE THE SHARKS OUT ,THERE ONLY GOING TO HAVE US TO EAT WHEN ALL THE FISH RUN OUT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Radman
WA, 629 posts
11 Oct 2011 4:47PM
Thumbs Up

dusta said...

Radman said...
that fish has been hanging around for weeks tell me it hasnt got a taste for it

being a shark expert do you have evidence that this shark , which hasn't even been spotted has been hanging around as you say ?

Please inform this "shark lover" how you came to your well informed decision .



get out there and find out for yourself it maybe a welldeformed descision

kyteryder
NSW, 692 posts
11 Oct 2011 7:51PM
Thumbs Up

Maybe the shark thought he was Tony Abbott

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
11 Oct 2011 4:58PM
Thumbs Up

Radman said...

dusta said...

Radman said...
that fish has been hanging around for weeks tell me it hasnt got a taste for it

being a shark expert do you have evidence that this shark , which hasn't even been spotted has been hanging around as you say ?

Please inform this "shark lover" how you came to your well informed decision .



get out there and find out for yourself it maybe a welldeformed descision

i'll happily go swimming , the chances of the shark still hanging around is none to ****all but i thought by your post and how well informed you are you could explain to me more how you came to your conclusion that it's been hanging around for weeks .

dbabicwa
WA, 809 posts
11 Oct 2011 5:05PM
Thumbs Up

I'm sure he was tagged.

They can track us now.

the gibbo
WA, 776 posts
11 Oct 2011 6:53PM
Thumbs Up

If they have tagged it and it hangs around, get rid of it.

That's my emotion talking, but my small brain says that getting rid of it will make no difference at all, senseless, because all the other sharks wont think "o my god they killed stevo cos he swam to close to the shore" they wont know, they dont think, just swim and eat. Where there is one gone another will replace it.
Its thier enviroment not ours

There is no right answer, i will take the small risk again this year and the next.....

Sorry to the family, rest in peace mate

stabber
NSW, 1114 posts
11 Oct 2011 10:18PM
Thumbs Up

Sorry to hear such bad news.....We need to creat a delacasy of GW sushi I say. With a side dish of Bull whaler stew.

Addikt
WA, 553 posts
11 Oct 2011 7:56PM
Thumbs Up

You can get bloody radiation detectors for iPhones today, technology is cheap why don't they take some of that money they waste on scuptures and the rest and place systems off our beaches on those bouys the council spent so much money on, surely there is some merit in the reaserch side of things as well as the peace of mind for all that use our beaches..........??????

RIP

bennie
ACT, 1258 posts
11 Oct 2011 11:22PM
Thumbs Up

A few months ago I saw on the ABC science programme catalyst that there is a popular holiday spot on the nsw coast that is regarded by marine biologists as a white shark congregation hotspot. They aren't sure why the white congregate there, but they do in large numbers at certain times of year. In the reported recent study over 100 different individuals were tagged and released within a 3 week period, right in the middle of holiday season. Most were tagged within 200m of the beach, popular for swimming and surfing. There have been very few atacks at this location.


Still I wouldn't go surfing there!

MIKO
QLD, 408 posts
11 Oct 2011 11:03PM
Thumbs Up

bennie said...

A few months ago I saw on the ABC science programme catalyst that there is a popular holiday spot on the nsw coast that is regarded by marine biologists as a white shark congregation hotspot. They aren't sure why the white congregate there, but they do in large numbers at certain times of year. In the reported recent study over 100 different individuals were tagged and released within a 3 week period, right in the middle of holiday season. Most were tagged within 200m of the beach, popular for swimming and surfing. There have been very few atacks at this location.


Still I wouldn't go surfing there!


Radman
WA, 629 posts
11 Oct 2011 10:06PM
Thumbs Up

dusta said...

Radman said...

dusta said...

Radman said...
that fish has been hanging around for weeks tell me it hasnt got a taste for it

being a shark expert do you have evidence that this shark , which hasn't even been spotted has been hanging around as you say ?

Please inform this "shark lover" how you came to your well informed decision .


five divers in cockburn sound tell a pretty good story of a large white spooking them as they hudled on the bottom wondering whitch way to sswim next,theres been other reports floating around ,do nt have to be a rocke t scientest to see a pattern forming,there cant be that many out there or is there,tuffen up bruiser givenm a kiss from the radman if you say you love them so mutch even better still strap a gopro to your head i want to see your shark loving footage or shud i say foot in the mouth footage
get out there and find out for yourself it maybe a welldeformed descision

i'll happily go swimming , the chances of the shark still hanging around is none to ****all but i thought by your post and how well informed you are you could explain to me more how you came to your conclusion that it's been hanging around for weeks .



jiggler1
WA, 17 posts
11 Oct 2011 11:57PM
Thumbs Up

Radman said...

dusta said...

Radman said...

dusta said...

Radman said...
that fish has been hanging around for weeks tell me it hasnt got a taste for it

being a shark expert do you have evidence that this shark , which hasn't even been spotted has been hanging around as you say ?

Please inform this "shark lover" how you came to your well informed decision .


five divers in cockburn sound tell a pretty good story of a large white spooking them as they hudled on the bottom wondering whitch way to sswim next,theres been other reports floating around ,do nt have to be a rocke t scientest to see a pattern forming,there cant be that many out there or is there,tuffen up bruiser givenm a kiss from the radman if you say you love them so mutch even better still strap a gopro to your head i want to see your shark loving footage or shud i say foot in the mouth footage
get out there and find out for yourself it maybe a welldeformed descision

i'll happily go swimming , the chances of the shark still hanging around is none to ****all but i thought by your post and how well informed you are you could explain to me more how you came to your conclusion that it's been hanging around for weeks .






Jiffrey
4 posts
12 Oct 2011 11:20AM
Thumbs Up

Pussies, get a land based sport if your fear of the ocean drives you to pointlessly killing protected creatures.

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
12 Oct 2011 11:39AM
Thumbs Up

swinginginthewind said...

Zed said...

On the plus side, my local is 2km out to sea, and every year there are fewer and fewer kiters So although I'm not that keen on windsurfing with sharks, they keep the kiters away [}:)]


Hey Zed,

that spot 2kms off shore is a good break in the right conditions, kite out there myself sometimes.

Got talking with the fishing charter guys on one of the boats from the marina, reckons there's a big female GW that calls that area home.

That said I have also dived out there a fair bit and have only seen reef sharks in some of the caves.



Yeah a few people have spotted a white out there. I've had a few long swims out there including one incident when I lost my board and had to swim for a hour.. at least I had the seals for company..

Adaswe
WA, 48 posts
12 Oct 2011 12:47PM
Thumbs Up


,if it's shark attacks on idiots swimming 1km out to sea during the whale migration season, then no. It's natures way of keeping the human race strong, by getting rid of stupid people.




Whats wrong with you mate?

Show some proper respect for this free man, who enjoyed the ocean to the fullest.
Also show some respect for his loved ones left with memories.

Lovely
QLD, 248 posts
12 Oct 2011 2:51PM
Thumbs Up

There will be some record times for the Rotto-Leighton race this year.

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
12 Oct 2011 3:58PM
Thumbs Up

Adaswe said...


,if it's shark attacks on idiots swimming 1km out to sea during the whale migration season, then no. It's natures way of keeping the human race strong, by getting rid of stupid people.




Whats wrong with you mate?

Show some proper respect for this free man, who enjoyed the ocean to the fullest.
Also show some respect for his loved ones left with memories.



Yup. Post edited.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing General


"Another Shark Attack?" started by tightlines