Woo! New site is online - select here to use it!


Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Perth trading hours -

Reply
Created by doggie > 9 months ago, 30 Sep 2010
getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
5 Oct 2010 3:01PM
Thumbs Up

Lost said sumpin like:

Well GF, you could be a winner. If you're so convinced about the duopoly then slap down some hard earned cash on their shares. Dividend payouts and by your assumptions a gauranteed return.

Again, I agree in most part, only I don't subscribe to the end of all that is fair in the world.

Like I said you adapt. I try to see an upside on most things. The upside for me is that extended hours didn't affect the way I shop - it simply gave me a choice.

What did change me, was the general price **EDIT** and quality of food, meat, fish etc. Because of this I have a daughter stoked with a vege patch, a boy with 4 chooks and a mate who cuts all our meat fresh. Yep, I pay extra, but it is sensational. Maybe reduced facelines, consolidation of brands, extended hours was just the push I needed??

Cheers and Beer Funky, I'm off to enjoy the sunset before the rain sets in for another 5 days...



Glad to hear you are prepared to spend extra time/energy/$$ for better quality Lost. So am I, hence my desire to see my local Farmer jacks (a true independant and better than IGA) survive, as they support and provide an outlet for superior West oz products such as milk, cheeses and honey etc.

Without them independants food in Perf will be dire.

I have only ever bought shares once and it is a sustainable energy company that may/may not be a windfall in the future.

My attempts at vege patching have been very hit n' miss over the last few years but they are an excellent source of free capsicums (which are normally very exxy) and motley also rans. Practice makes edible tho.

BTW - re: holidays I should have added my next fam holiday will be camping Moore river. We had Grotto booked but cancelled - I kn hate the rip-orf that Grotto is. Funnily enough that is entirely due to a monopoly situation there (no kidding) and the place just doesn't add up at all anymore.

Our next big holiday may be campervanning the Mid/Nth Eastern coast, but it depends on fundage and won't be for at least a year.


Cheers yaself Lost - it's windy out and I'm goin kiting sarvo!! After that it's beer o' clock.

Diver
WA, 554 posts
5 Oct 2010 3:05PM
Thumbs Up

Lost...

Sorry for butting in on your argument with Funky (vile West Coast supporter he is)

Change happens, fair enough. But it seems strange that you attack the WA mind set concerning people from the Eastern States to support your arguement(s).

Open the shops up, extend trading hours and let us all pretend what a sophisticated group of consumers we are. In the meatime pay through the nose, wonder why you and are your friends are so tired and stressed, and why the quality of life you once had is gone.

Profits of large corporations are a function of the number of shopping hours and spending for instant gratification. Maybe there is resistance because we feel that our quality of life in WA is being threatened, and that we don't buy the argument that tells us otherwise.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
5 Oct 2010 3:11PM
Thumbs Up

Geez that Diver makes sense... for a vile Docker supporter.

Problem over here IMO is the transient mining employees earn unrealistic coin, compared to those that live here and work outside mining, (ie the majority of us) and spend like there is no tomorrow on everything in sight and then some.

It is those temporarily cashed up folks - out of touch with the reality of the majority - that demand 24 hr consumer indulgence and it is they that lost the referedum on extended trading.

Yet, here we are with extended trading foisted onto us by a govt lobbied by big business and ignoring the majority view plus WA retail/primary industries.

Bloody ordinary IMO.


And... I think I have more than spent my 2c as usual.

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
5 Oct 2010 7:36PM
Thumbs Up

getfunky said...

Lost said sumpin like:

Well GF, you could be a winner. If you're so convinced about the duopoly then slap down some hard earned cash on their shares. Dividend payouts and by your assumptions a gauranteed return.

Again, I agree in most part, only I don't subscribe to the end of all that is fair in the world.

Like I said you adapt. I try to see an upside on most things. The upside for me is that extended hours didn't affect the way I shop - it simply gave me a choice.

What did change me, was the general price **EDIT** and quality of food, meat, fish etc. Because of this I have a daughter stoked with a vege patch, a boy with 4 chooks and a mate who cuts all our meat fresh. Yep, I pay extra, but it is sensational. Maybe reduced facelines, consolidation of brands, extended hours was just the push I needed??

Cheers and Beer Funky, I'm off to enjoy the sunset before the rain sets in for another 5 days...



Glad to hear you are prepared to spend extra time/energy/$$ for better quality Lost. So am I, hence my desire to see my local Farmer jacks (a true independant and better than IGA) survive, as they support and provide an outlet for superior West oz products such as milk, cheeses and honey etc.

Without them independants food in Perf will be dire.

I have only ever bought shares once and it is a sustainable energy company that may/may not be a windfall in the future.

My attempts at vege patching have been very hit n' miss over the last few years but they are an excellent source of free capsicums (which are normally very exxy) and motley also rans. Practice makes edible tho.

BTW - re: holidays I should have added my next fam holiday will be camping Moore river. We had Grotto booked but cancelled - I kn hate the rip-orf that Grotto is. Funnily enough that is entirely due to a monopoly situation there (no kidding) and the place just doesn't add up at all anymore.

Our next big holiday may be campervanning the Mid/Nth Eastern coast, but it depends on fundage and won't be for at least a year.


Cheers yaself Lost - it's windy out and I'm goin kiting sarvo!! After that it's beer o' clock.


What I wanna know GF is when did petermac die and why are you channeling his spirit?

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
5 Oct 2010 4:53PM
Thumbs Up

I bet PM33 is reading this rite now.

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
6 Oct 2010 10:47AM
Thumbs Up

One day my foil hat came loose and next thing I know I was euphoric with a flouride rush.. at that point extended trading made complete sense.

gs12
WA, 426 posts
6 Oct 2010 8:43PM
Thumbs Up

I checked seabreeze after few days' and I'm surprised this is still going on

I predict this thread will eventually have more posts & pages then funny images, top jokes & chemtrails combined, crash the server and will be deleted by admins as "politics related thread". This will start another great conspiracy/controversy debate which will divide seabreeze users more than kitesurfing vs windsurfing ever could (and crash the server three times in the process).

Give it up people! It's happening in few weeks and there is nothing you can do about it.

The only thing that can save us is early arrival of regular seabreeze, I think we all need a good dose of that!

Pugwash
WA, 7733 posts
6 Oct 2010 10:38PM
Thumbs Up

The pimply faced teenager is growing up...

commentking
1 posts
17 Oct 2010 11:11PM
Thumbs Up

Mandurah gunning for longer shopping hours than Perth ...

www.oneperth.com.au/2010/10/17/mandurah-demands-longer-shop-hours-than-perth/

This shopping hours thing is a joke.

Get the government out of my life.

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
1 Nov 2010 4:02PM
Thumbs Up

Extended shop trading hours to 9pm on weeknights have come into effect in Perth.

New laws that came into force on Monday give general retail shops, including major grocery stores, the option to open later during the week.

Western Australia's shop trading hours have long lagged behind the more liberal extended opening times in other states.

Premier Colin Barnett and Commerce Minister Bill Marmion announced the changes at a shopping centre at suburban Mount Hawthorn on Monday.

Mr Barnett said the changes reflected his government's determination to reform WA's shopping laws to allow more choice, flexibility and competition.

"Business will now have greater freedom to respond to particular needs of their customers and won't be locked into outdated shopping hours," he said.

Mr Marmion said the government was determined to keep pace with changes in urban lifestyles and working hours in the Perth metropolitan area.

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
1 Nov 2010 7:25PM
Thumbs Up

Maybe you Perfians can quiz the pollies about this on Q&A tonight (ABC 9:35 pm AEDST). It's being beamed live from there and hosts a bevvy of WA pollies, including premier Colin Barnett.

Somebody please go to the studio and give Julie Bishop an unending death stare for the rest of us. I swear that woman could have a starring role in V as one of the reptile aliens. HEY!!! DO YA THINK
.
Oops! No conspiracies...

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
1 Nov 2010 4:33PM
Thumbs Up

JB freaks me right out.

She is my local MP.

Wish I was in the audience tonight.[}:)]

Have done a bit of homework and found a farmer's markets in reasonable reach for semi-regular trips. Before long they will regular trips to the markets - especially with the steady decline in independants (that are required to pay weekend staff penalties - unlike Moles and Foolies).

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
1 Nov 2010 5:20PM
Thumbs Up

everyone get their tin foil hats on quickly .

All this talk of people's family lives being affected well i call bull**** . Everyone of you who has pulled that line are you directly affected by this or are you just hopping on the DLS bandwagon and not wanting change in perth .

Personally i am all for it . I don't have time to shop on a weekend as i am either kiting, boating or something else equally valuable with my time and i work long hours . So if i can shop at 9pm on a tuesday ****ing awesome .



Carantoc
WA, 7301 posts
1 Nov 2010 9:10PM
Thumbs Up

Most of the anti arguments seem to be based around industrial relations and competativeness issues

Ignoring whether I agree or disagree with extended trading hours or whether I think it will cause suffering to the employee or small business operator I can't help but think that worker protection and anti-competativeness should not
be controlled through the right to operate your business at certains times.

Should they not be controlled through IR legislation and the ACCC ?

Is it not like controlling speeding through a tax on petrol ? The faster you drive the more petrol you burn so more tax will slow people down, but not a very good way of doing it. I kinda think that retail trading hours legislation is the same.

spot1
WA, 1588 posts
1 Nov 2010 9:39PM
Thumbs Up

i need some milk sweet shop is still open about bl#$% time

gazza
WA, 647 posts
1 Nov 2010 10:44PM
Thumbs Up

coles online.
Have only been in a supermarket about 10 times in over a year.

Someone goes around the store picks out your food and then drops it off to your house,they even deliver a carton of cold beers for you all for $13.
Ours came tonight at 7pm was in the cupboards by 7.10pm.

Get with the times who needs to waste time at the shops lol




Mark _australia
WA, 23726 posts
1 Nov 2010 10:55PM
Thumbs Up

dusta said...

everyone get their tin foil hats on quickly .

Personally i am all for it . I don't have time to shop on a weekend as i am either kiting, boating or something else equally valuable with my time and i work long hours . So if i can shop at 9pm on a tuesday ****ing awesome .






Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.

And I thought many of the pro extended trading people were talking about how they just can't find any time to shop. Is this what they meant by "can't"?



And Spotto - you always could buy milk in the evening if you had a lack of foresight / forgot / had unexpected guests demanding a coffee.
You just paid a little tiny bit (like 10%) more.
Now everyone will pay more, to help out the few who need to shop every damn night.

mattyjee
WA, 575 posts
2 Nov 2010 8:20AM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...
Now everyone will pay more


Absolute crap.
What have you based this on?

maxm
NSW, 864 posts
2 Nov 2010 12:10PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...

Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.


May surprise you Mark, but there are probably people out there happy to work those hours so Dusta can go out and play on Saturday morning. Why do you want to deny them the opportunity?

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
2 Nov 2010 9:47AM
Thumbs Up

maxm said...

Mark _australia said...

Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.


May surprise you Mark, but there are probably people out there happy to work those hours so Dusta can go out and play on Saturday morning. Why do you want to deny them the opportunity?


True that maxm, & wouldnt it make more employment for those who could use it like students ect? Just a thought..

Mark _australia
WA, 23726 posts
2 Nov 2010 9:47AM
Thumbs Up

mattyjee said...

Mark _australia said...
Now everyone will pay more


Absolute crap.
What have you based this on?


Simple. Fixed number of people spend the same amount.
But shop overheads go up. They have to go up if the shops are open longer. That has already happened with small retailers being told their rents are going up as the shopping centre will be open longer.

Secondly, once it is easier for Coles and Woolies to compete with IGA etc who were allowed to open longer, their duopoly will increase and they can put prices up. It is naive to think that when they can put prices up that they somehow will not due to some social responsibility warm fuzzy feeling. Of course they will.

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
2 Nov 2010 10:01AM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...

mattyjee said...

Mark _australia said...
Now everyone will pay more


Absolute crap.
What have you based this on?


Simple. Fixed number of people spend the same amount.
But shop overheads go up. They have to go up if the shops are open longer. That has already happened with small retailers being told their rents are going up as the shopping centre will be open longer.

Secondly, once it is easier for Coles and Woolies to compete with IGA etc who were allowed to open longer, their duopoly will increase and they can put prices up. It is naive to think that when they can put prices up that they somehow will not due to some social responsibility warm fuzzy feeling. Of course they will.


More jobs, more money = more spending. Is that how it works?

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
2 Nov 2010 1:35PM
Thumbs Up

maxm said...

Mark _australia said...

Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.


May surprise you Mark, but there are probably people out there happy to work those hours so Dusta can go out and play on Saturday morning. Why do you want to deny them the opportunity?

And you know what if shops want to stay open longer and charge a little more for staying open later i would happily pay for that .

westozwind
WA, 1419 posts
2 Nov 2010 1:54PM
Thumbs Up

Since the referendum on trading hours was a waste of time, can we do the same with the Daylight Savings one too?
Time to put DLS through the parliament and ride rough shod over those pathetic DLS "No" voters

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
2 Nov 2010 2:07PM
Thumbs Up

westozwind said...

Since the referendum on trading hours was a waste of time, can we do the same with the Daylight Savings one too?
Time to put DLS through the parliament and ride rough shod over those pathetic DLS "No" voters


+1

Mark _australia
WA, 23726 posts
2 Nov 2010 4:23PM
Thumbs Up

dusta said...

maxm said...

Mark _australia said...

Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.


May surprise you Mark, but there are probably people out there happy to work those hours so Dusta can go out and play on Saturday morning. Why do you want to deny them the opportunity?

And you know what if shops want to stay open longer and charge a little more for staying open later i would happily pay for that .


That was already the case!!! The independents like IGA and mum n dad deli's could!!
So far your argument is that you don't mind paying more for convenience (which was the case already, you always could buy milk at midnight) and that you want to go sailing or whatever on the weekend.
Sorry, but not a well reasoned argument I think.


Doggie said "More jobs, more money = more spending. Is that how it works?"
Not necessarily. Big companies are more inclined to do creative rostering like split shifts and so on to minimise the cost to them. They are in the business of money, not social responsibility or being nice. When Coles and Woolies open, let's say 30% longer hours now, if they put on 30% extra employees or spend 30% extra on wages I'll believe you but I really doubt it will happen.
Seriously, who would trust Coles and Woolies on this issue, when they already do stuff like forcing primary producers to deal with them and then pay them less, or dropping prices to unsustainable levels to kill off the competitor around the corner and when the competitors are gone the prices go back up????

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
2 Nov 2010 4:56PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...

dusta said...

maxm said...

Mark _australia said...

Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.


May surprise you Mark, but there are probably people out there happy to work those hours so Dusta can go out and play on Saturday morning. Why do you want to deny them the opportunity?

And you know what if shops want to stay open longer and charge a little more for staying open later i would happily pay for that .


That was already the case!!! The independents like IGA and mum n dad deli's could!!
So far your argument is that you don't mind paying more for convenience (which was the case already, you always could buy milk at midnight) and that you want to go sailing or whatever on the weekend.
Sorry, but not a well reasoned argument I think.


Doggie said "More jobs, more money = more spending. Is that how it works?"
Not necessarily. Big companies are more inclined to do creative rostering like split shifts and so on to minimise the cost to them. They are in the business of money, not social responsibility or being nice. When Coles and Woolies open, let's say 30% longer hours now, if they put on 30% extra employees or spend 30% extra on wages I'll believe you but I really doubt it will happen.
Seriously, who would trust Coles and Woolies on this issue, when they already do stuff like forcing primary producers to deal with them and then pay them less, or dropping prices to unsustainable levels to kill off the competitor around the corner and when the competitors are gone the prices go back up????



Wot e sayd.

Why is it ok for Moles n Foolies to open the same hours but not have to pay their staff basic awards that all Ozzies expect in every job?

We are creating an under-class of workers stuck in poverty - strung along behind the split-shift, no penatlies carrots (just as M+F do to primary producers too) and sh!tting in our own nest simultaneously coz we want the choice to sh!t there. [Insert your choice of grogan here]

Sigh..

doggie
WA, 15849 posts
2 Nov 2010 5:16PM
Thumbs Up

Mark _australia said...

dusta said...

maxm said...

Mark _australia said...

Dusta and I getting this right?
"somebody else can work, so I can go play instead of taking one hour of my Saturday morning to buy groceries"

Very giving and caring of you.


May surprise you Mark, but there are probably people out there happy to work those hours so Dusta can go out and play on Saturday morning. Why do you want to deny them the opportunity?

And you know what if shops want to stay open longer and charge a little more for staying open later i would happily pay for that .


That was already the case!!! The independents like IGA and mum n dad deli's could!!
So far your argument is that you don't mind paying more for convenience (which was the case already, you always could buy milk at midnight) and that you want to go sailing or whatever on the weekend.
Sorry, but not a well reasoned argument I think.


Doggie said "More jobs, more money = more spending. Is that how it works?"
Not necessarily. Big companies are more inclined to do creative rostering like split shifts and so on to minimise the cost to them. They are in the business of money, not social responsibility or being nice. When Coles and Woolies open, let's say 30% longer hours now, if they put on 30% extra employees or spend 30% extra on wages I'll believe you but I really doubt it will happen.
Seriously, who would trust Coles and Woolies on this issue, when they already do stuff like forcing primary producers to deal with them and then pay them less, or dropping prices to unsustainable levels to kill off the competitor around the corner and when the competitors are gone the prices go back up????



I see what you are saying there mate but its not just the big guys that this affects, small shops will be able to do the same so there will be more hours for everybody, there has to be.

Cassa
WA, 1305 posts
2 Nov 2010 6:50PM
Thumbs Up

Well I couldnt care less, longer shopping or not , sounds like most here are wage earners , have to be there at a designated time and cant leave until the time bell rings .
Have been a subcontractor all my life , and would't have it any other way, can arrive when I please and go whenever I want {will never forget the day at work in Gero when the wind TURNED OFFSHORE !!! AT 11am , packed up and had an awsome day } I could NEVER work on the timeclock system,
as for the extra cost in allowing the extra shopping time , like I really care --- not.
Half an hour extra during the week and I have it all covered.(not that I need to shop)
An old macadonian mate of mine once said (with an accent ) boy,,,,, the more you put,, the more you get, but I guess that doesn't apply to wage earners
I truely love the freedom my job gives me and wouldn't have it any other way.
If the importance of being able to shop when you want and you can't , change something in your life.

Mister Dugong
368 posts
2 Nov 2010 11:45PM
Thumbs Up

I usually agree with doggie coz he says boobs, but mark is right, extended shopping hours are giving more money to ceo's and share holders at the expense of employees. You should think of this the next time you hear about unionists trying to get a pay rise. Public or private somewhere up the ladder a person is trying to get paid more and they dont care about you.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Perth trading hours -" started by doggie